| 2023 |
1st Team - Riley Gerhardt, Georgie Mageo, Jahidi West, Paco Baltazar, Jacob Romero
2nd Team - Justice Bice, Troy Dietz, Georgia Mageo, Micah Olson, Emanuel Spiyee |
| 2022 |
1st Team - Sammy Trejo, Justice Bice, Riley Gerhardt
2nd Team - Troy Dietz, Jahidi West, Dustin Kasowski |
| 2021 |
1st Team - Justice Bice, Sammy Trejo, Nick Radunz, Troy Dietz, Jorun Hamre, Riley Gerhardt, Jerrod Williamson, Marshaun Jones, Jahidi West
2nd Team - Martin Jones, Garrett Pemelton, Sal Avila, Michael Cornelious, Jalen Pfeifer, Benjamin Dumond
|
| 2020 |
1st Team - Sal Avila, Marshaun Jones, Jerrod Williamson, Troy Dietz, Sammy Trejo, Jorun Hamre
2nd Team - Jalen Pfeifer, Taylor Simmons, Berkley Santos, Benjamin Dumond, Dustin Kasowski
|
| 2019 |
1st Team - Louis Quinones, JohnL Jones, Jake Peterson, Arron Martin, Marshaun Jones, Doniaj Smelker
2nd Team - Spencer Dorsey, Sal Avila, Andrew Hanretty, Landon Arredondo, Louis Quinones (kick returner) |
| 2018 |
1st Team -Â Tyler Masat, Hunter Slemmons, Austin Erickson, Arron Martin, Travon Smith, JohnL Jones, Landon Arredondo, Louis Quinones
2nd Team - Marc Wagner, Louis Quinones, Dahlton Wasankari, Jake Peterson, Darius Graves, Riley Fredrickson, Andrew Hanretty
|
| 2017 |
1st Team - Louis Quinones, Avery Lock, Tayler Lentz, Jake Peterson, Darius Graves, Nicholas McBeain, Travon Smith
2nd Team - PJ Peterson, Tyler Masat, Jesus Munoz, Landon Arredondo
|
| 2016 |
1st Team - Nicholas McBeain, Andre Peppers, Jawuan Pugh, Avery Lock, Tayler Lentz
2nd Team - Kurtis Walls, Colby Lum, PJ Peterson, Ben Bruenjes, Travon Smith, Harvey McMahon
|
| 2015 |
1st Team - Colby Lum, Landon Freitas, Jawuan Pugh, DaMario Fair
2nd Team - Lex Tande, Mychael Bruce, Andre Peppers, Ethen Preston, Nick McBeain, Harvey McMahon
|
| 2014 |
1st Team - Kurtis Walls, Jake Miller, Antoine Griffin, George Trujillo, Avery Lock, Nick McBeain, Jawuan Pugh, Mychael Bruce, Thomas Cortes.
2nd Team - Zach Johnson, Landon Freitas, Sam Cooke, Ben Bruenjes
|
| 2013 |
Derek Elliott, Jake Thurston, George Trujillo, Gustavo Ramirez, Jacob Miller, Thomas Cortes, Matt Craft, Dwanye Fearon |
| 2012 |
Aaron Freije, Garrett Jackson, Jake Thurston, Thomas Cortes, Ken Eliacin,Derek Elliot, George Trujillo, Tommy Zinke |
| 2011 |
Ken Eliacin, Cody Kilthau, Jordan Maher, Jake Thurston, Major Hopp, Tommy Zinke, LeTheo Proctor, A.J. Pfeifer |
| 2010 |
Kevin Strang, Derek Elliott, Ken Eliacin, Garrett Jackson, Coty Beck, Cody Kilthau |
| 2009 |
Jason Hollett, Kevin Strang, Tommy Butler |
| 2008 |
Chauncey Calhoun, Kevin Strang, Jason Beilke, Jason Hollett, Dan Hill, David Durr |
| 2007 |
Anthony Walkine-Levy, Chauncey Calhoun, Jason Hollett, Michael Hollett, Dustin Brandt, Tony Jenkins |
| 2006 |
Ryan Drinkwater, Justin Folk, Joe Maresh, Chauncey Calhoun, Brad Elliot, Jason Beilke, Ben Picard, Dustin Brandt, Quentin Sterling, Tony Jenkins |
| 2005 |
Travis Lester, Joe Maresh, B.J. Ingram, Barrett Sczepanski, Chad Lueck, Rochenel Absolu, Bryce Kilmer, Chauncey Calhoun, Jeremy Payne |
| 2004 |
Kenard Walker, Rochenel Absolu, Josh Kasowski, Paul Mehle, Travis Lester, Barrett Sczepanski |
| 2003 |
Tony Hart, Josh Kasowski, Mark Fabian, Travis Anderson |
| 2002 |
Steve Battle, Garitt Irey, Jon Kleinke, Josh Komarek, Jimmy Newton, Tony Hart, Frank Sowitch, David Rowe |
| 2001 |
Jeremy Peschel, Steve Battle, Justin Wieseler, Brent Miller, Mike Silbernagel, Ben Aarestad, David Rowe, James Thornton, J.O. Thielges, Josh Komarek, Mike Rowe |
| 2000 |
Jeremy Peschel, Mark Rerick, Steve Battle, Darin Walters, Ben Aarestad, James Thornton, Brent Miller, Randy Mittleider, Mike Rowe |
| 1999 |
Ben King, Darin Walters, Ben Aarestad, David Woods, Randall Mittleider, Brent Miller |
| 1998 |
Ken Terry, Bryan Niewind, Scott Kopp, Kevin Wilk |
| 1997 |
Ken Terry, Sarge Truesdell, George Perich, Trevor Bakalar, Al Guerrero, Scott Kopp, Max Miranda, Ryan Magee, Bryan Niewind |
| 1996 |
Gerald Urlaub, Mikah Boudreaux, Trevor Bakalar, Mark Pippin, Ray Reinhart, Sarge Truesdell, George Perich, Max Miranda, Ned Clooten, Jeff Baker, Marcus Hooks, Kevin Trotter |
| 1995 |
Dan Rohrbach, Gerald Urlaub, Ned Clooten, Mikah Boudreaux, George Perich, Eli Davis, Trevor Bakalar |
| 1994 |
Elijah Davis, Steve Gaskin |
| 1993 |
Mike Guardipee, Dan Rohrbach |
| 1992 |
Mike Guardipee, Tucker Sturdevant, Andrew Warcken, Mark Tichkowsky |
| 1991 |
Joe Peterson, Brent Keith, Tony Fast, Pat Richter |
| 1990 |
Gene Gregory, Joe Peterson, Tom Smargiassi, Lloyd Joseph, Andy Warcken |
| 1989 |
Don Lennon, Don Lingen, Lloyd Joseph, Andy Williams |
| 1988 |
Darin Loe, Tyler Schlecht, Steve Quinn, Pat Klubben, Lloyd Joseph |
| 1987 |
Darin Loe, Tyler Schlecht, Kevin Grage, Todd Hoffner, Aaron Kramlich, Dave Schramm, Marty Hochhalter, Lloyd Joseph |
| 1986 |
Darin Loe, Dave Schramm, Rick Bier, Brad Dwyer, Larry Schafer |
| 1985 |
Doug Schindele, Randy Peitz, Pat Horner, Brian Ringdahl, Dean Belter, Rod Skytland |
| 1984 |
Pat Horner, Pat O'Brien, Chris Lima, Steve Becher, Troy Johnson |
| 1983 |
Jim Theis, Jed Klein, Mike Smith, Jeff Volk, Randy Peitz |
| 1982 |
Paul Leier, Jim Theis, Steve Guenther |
| 1981 |
Jon Bolstad, Steve Guenther, Kevin Dockter, Warren King |
| 1980 |
Doug Black, Mike Callahan, Kevin Dockter, Steve Guenther, Jeff Hooey, Pete Hughes, Jeff Pederson, Tyrone Sampson, Mark Smetana |
| 1979 |
John Overbey, Jeff Leech, Bruce Schmith, Pete Hughes, Mike Callahan |
| 1978 |
Eric Jorgenson, Kyle Stricklin, Lyall Krueger, Tom Stevenson, Davy Zinke |
| 1977 |
Buck Kasowski, David Rausch, Jim Ukestad, Randy Betsinger, Jon Achter, Dave Olson, Jerry Holinka, Eric Jorgenson, Steve Leier |
| 1976 |
Jerome Huck, Randy Betsinger, Jim Ukestad, Dave Rausch, Buck Kasowski, Tim Webber |
| 1975 |
Larry Boschee, Buck Kasowski, Mike Tenuto, John Thomas, Jim Ukestad |
| 1974 |
Tim Daniels, Glen Schmalz, Tom Sturdevant, Mike Tenuto |
| 1973 |
Bill Cahill, Mark Nordeen, Mike Tenuto, Gary Theisen, Rocky Truax |
| 1972 |
Jim Juelke, Bill Cahill, Steve Carlson, Harry Fass, Gary Thiesen, Mark Nordeen |
| 1970 |
Tom Hatleli, Virgil Hollen |
| 1969 |
Gary Garman, Virgil Hollen |
| 1968 |
Eugene Boyle, Dick Vandrovec, Tim Schilling |
| 1966 |
Willard Jantzen, Bill Kyvig, Bob McKenzie |
| 1965 |
Bruce Jacobson, Del Schwartz, Larry Ukestad |
| 1964 |
Lester Hintz, Ed Miller, Jim Johnson, Del Schwartz, Larry Ukestad, Bruce Jacobson |
| 1963 |
Don Kropp, John Welk, Hank Toring, Jim Johnson, Del Scwartz, Mike Sheldon, Don Odegard |
| 1962 |
Don Kropp, Jim Ramey, John Welk |
| 1961 |
Ray Murdock |
| 1960 |
Bill Svenkesen, Ray Murdock |
| 1959 |
Mike Vanyo, Tom Aichele |
| 1958 |
Jim Bock, Bill Thomas |
| 1957 |
James Bock, Gerald Ringdahl |
| 1954 |
Bob King, Jerry Olson, LaRoi Robertson |
| 1953 |
Gus Lybeck, Frank Vetter, Leo Longnecker, Al Dosch |
| 1950 |
Bob Lentz, Larry Stenshoel, Marvin Carlson |
| 1948 |
Buzz Ratzlaff, Lowell Noack, Joe Humphrey, Ray Koll |
| 1947 |
Dale Noack, Leonard Ratzlaff, John Richards |
| 1946 |
Joe Humphrey, Floyd Lahay |
| 1933 |
Spriggs, Shoonover |
| 1927 |
Fred Tauber, Fiola, Slitterman, Eckel, Darkenwald, Elias, L. Tauber, Clavadestcher |
| 1926 |
Fiola, Eckel, Polyhar, Gray, Simonsen, Brockmeier |
| 1925 |
Darkenwald, Conrad, Dale |
